I’m a painter so I obviously think paint and stain first, but if you are interested in a low-difficulty, high-quality, low-maintenance floor, this post will take you there. Our paint/stain posts are linked at the bottom, but this is just for garage flooring coating alternatives.
There are some big drawbacks other websites are not telling you.
There’s only one good non-paint, non-stain option in my opinion, and it is interlocking tiles. We will publish soon an article dedicated to that.
In this article, we will cover:
- Interlocking Tiles: this is the best option
- Why the other options are less cost-effective
- VCT: Vinyl Composite Tiles
- Rollout Mats
- Misc Options: (Peel and stick tiles, carpet tiles)
Although porcelain tile is a great choice, I won’t review it here because it’s so pricey. But read this great article from VaultGarage.com.
A note on cost:
Compare the ballpark costs with these coatings (from my full post on garage floor paints: 1-K, 2-K epoxies, and garage floor paint:
- about .60¢ per foot … for 2-K epoxy paint
- about 14¢ per foot … for one-step epoxy paint
- about .08¢ per foot … for normal garage floor paint
(All the garage floor coating options below ship for free)
1. Best Option: Interlocking tiles
If you want to do this job once, and never think about it again, go with interlocking tiles. There was so many good choices, we made a separate article just on them. This is a 10-minute read with the best value in garage floor tiles.
The samples various sellers sent to me are all very hard plastic and seem very durable.
2. Why the other options below are not as good
Interlocking tiles above are the only ones that will set you free. But the rest below all have good points, just not great. They all have weaknesses (but cost less).
I have looked through almost all of the offerings on the market and have put the best value tiles for you here.
- Self-stick tiles, roll-out mats, or vinyl composite tile (VCT) often do not line up well when laid and move over time, even when properly installed. The punishment of a ½ ton rolling can be too much.
- Plus, garage floors get wet, and mold grows if water is trapped underneath.
- Moisture breaks down some glues when it gets between the tiles. Mold never sleeps, Neil.
- One option I did not research is porcelain, not ceramic. Ceramic breaks, but the porcelain can be a great (but very, very expensive) option. It’s for the Mitt Romney’s of the world and their car-elevator type garages.
I’ll list the best of the rest here, just for you budget-conscious…but I highly recommend that you read the interlocking post and forget the rest of this list!
Are you a professional? If you want to learn the details of standards for laying flooring over concrete, you can buy a PDF for 50 clams from the ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials).
3. Vinyl Composite Tiles (VCT): cost almost as much as interlocking
Vinyl composite tile for a garage floor is mostly easy to install if you like this kind of thing. These are the same sturdy tiles that you see in stores and schools that are can be buffed to a high glossy shine.
My logic: these cost almost as much as the interlocking tiles, but are nothing like that quality. I know some readers will want it anyway so here you are.
The key to keeping these tiles in place is to use the best adhesive and disregard the cost. Lower-grade adhesive will allow the tiles to move from the weight of the vehicles. At the bottom of this section, you will find the best glue out there.
The best of this is G-Floor’s RaceDay tiles: hands-down winner. Check them here.
- Installation: moderately easy
- Size: 1-feet to 2-feet square by 1/8” thick
- Glued into place (described below)
- Good resistance to oils, salt, stains
- U.V. resistant
- Tiles are mold and mildew resistant (but water can get under them too)
- Size: 1-foot square (you will find other makers with 2′ sq.)
- Cost: expensive (generally about 4 bucks/foot – same as top quality interlocking)
- Require waxing, buffing to keep free of marks
- Installation: not as easy as interlocking tiles since the cement floor must be cleaned and prepped properly to accept the adhesive
- VCT is best suited for temperate climates or a heated garage because damp subfloors and temps below 55 degrees F can cause bonding problems.
- It’s also slippery when wet and is susceptible to staining from salt and other chemicals (but damaged tiles are inexpensive to replace)
- Not recommended by the manufacturer for use in garages, but many people do
How to install:
- Degrease floor (we use GP66: Made in the USA since ’66) and rinse very well.
- Let dry fully. Use fans heaters if you can.
- Trowel on adhesive and lay the tile.
- Wait one week then coat with three or more coats of clear sealer of your choice (or not).
Roberts Universal Vinyl Flooring Adhesive is great, but the price is reasonable.
4. Rollout mats
G-Floor Coin Garage Floor Mat
- 4 colors and 6 sizes of mats
- Installation: extremely easy: sweep, unroll the flooring, trim edges with a utility knife
- Easy to clean and move
- Cost: about 2.5 bucks per foot
- Very durable
- Can get stained from tires and chemicals
- Can be gouged with gravel or car jacks
- Expand and contract with temperature
The best-rated and best value we found was IncStores in 6 styles and many sizes, at 1.6mm thick, it will be very durable for sure. It comes to about 1.5 to 2.5¢ per foot, depending on how much you buy.
My advice: paint a garage floor coating around the edges and just buy one big rollout mat for the center of your space
5. Misc other types of garage floor coverings
Peel and Stick Garage Floor Tile: 2 decent choices
There is one brand that rises above the rest: the makers of the G-Floor mat above, but you have to prime your garage floor before you lay this tile, or you void the warranty. Makes sense. Primer linked below.
G-Floor Raceday Tread Peel and Stick Floor Tile
- Installation: extremely easy: adhesive comes already on the back: just peel and press with your body weight
- Size: 1-foot square
- Cost: about 4 – 5 bucks/ft² depending on color
- These tiles are slightly thicker than the mats from the same company
- So no messy adhesive is required
- Don’t require any waxing
- Stays flexible
- Slightly thicker than a quarter and have an adhesive pressure sensitive backing
- Matted tread pattern
- Polyvinyl (not layered: this is solid vinyl)
- Resistant to oil, other auto liquids, saltwater, etc.
- 5-year limited manufacturer warranty
- Turning the steering wheel while the car is still will rip the tile out
- Tires can leave marks, but it is a garage (get black for the extra dollar per foot)
For concrete floors, I use only one masonry primer, this one (Benjamin Moore Ultra Spec Acrylic Masonry Sealer) and it is second to none. Read about how to get the concrete floor ready, and how to apply the primer. This is never a bad idea before you lay down any garage floor coating.
How to install:
- Lay the tile on a dry floor, which should have a dry fresh coat of primer
- Determine the first row and lay it carefully, then follow with the rest
- At the edges, use a razor knife
- Full installation instructions come with
Achim Home Furnishings Vinyl Tile comes in different styles: you’ll love the price, but of course you get what you pay for.
- About 55¢ per 12-inch tile
- No wax
- Slightly thinner than a dime…that’s thin man
- Made in the big country that is not the USA, if you know what I mean
- Intended for home interiors, not garages, but people do put in a garage
- Garage floor coating on an extreme budget
Carpet Tiles (Carpet Squares)
Achim’s Carpet Tiles ( you can see them here) are about one dollar each depending on your style.
- Installation: moderately easy
- Ribbed for your foot’s pleasure
- peel and stick
- 1-foot square tiles
- Cost: about 1 buck per foot
- 6 colors
- Mold/Mildew resistant
- Buy extras to replace in the future
- Be sure to fill major cracks in your floor before you lay the tile: this filler is excellent
We have other posts about stain, paint, epoxy, etc: every traditional garage floor coating.
Before considering any garage floor coating, even tiles, but especially paints etc, it’s important to test the moisture and sometimes test the alkalinity of concrete
Paint and epoxy are is the garage floor coating I have applied many times and is very durable: read all about garage floor paints.
Read about how to apply the paint: done right it’s a long term garage floor coating. This is for applying primer also.
3 thoughts on “All Garage Floor Coating Alternatives: Beyond Paint and Stain”
Thank you for taking the time to share this very informative article about garage floor coating. I agree that you should always ask for professional contractors regarding the garage floor coating. It would be best if you considered everything.
I’ve been asked to repaint the floor of a lanai in Florida that is exposed to the elements and has failing 1 part Behr epoxy paint and a sealer over that,I’m looking for a bonding primer to put down so I won’t have to scuff up the whole thing before I recoat it with a better product what would you recommend?
Hi. I put this comment here because I’m assuming the floor is concrete, right? You did not mention it.
Well, you’re in for a long weekend for sure. I cannot tell exactly the problem, so the advice that follows is only an opinion and you should not trust it without the advice of a professional painter on the site!
If you are a doing this for money or compensation, before starting, I would re-negotiate the price! This is going to be hard work, and it’s not going to last very long.
The fault lies with whoever decided to put this product down. My guess is that it was not prepped correctly and is failing for that reason. But Behr is not known to be the best.
I don’t want to dump on HD paints, but they are less expensive for a reason.
Best approach: remove all the old coatings. If not…
My approach would be to contact a local paint store and discuss this: they will know the elements better than me, and give you a good product suggestion.
Here is the basic list:
1-pressure wash and try to remove all that is loose-try to get ALL of it off-, 2-scrape and sand the edges of what is not loose
3- Use masonry primer on the concrete where it is bare, and make sure what paint/clear sealer that is left is sanded very well: it must be deglossed to bond to the next coat. Perhaps the primer to use on the old clear sealer is this one.
Then use the best floor paint you can afford. And no more clear coating!
Don’t make any guarantee and in fact you might explain all this and get it in writing…assuming you are a pro.